California-American Water Company Current Issues
Cease and Desist Order Compliance Reporting
Cal-Am Order WR 2016-0016/WR 2009-0060 Quarterly Reports (see "State Water Resources Control Board Cease and Desist Order")
- Cal-Am Quarterly Reports
- Cal-Am Certification of Milestone 1 Completion (9/27/2016)
- Cal-Am Certification of Milestone 2 Completion (6/12/2017)
- Cal-Am Certification of Milestone 3 Progress (6/5/2018)
Interpretation and Implementation of Condition 2 of Order WR 2009-0060
- Luke Coletti Comments (3/15/2018)
- Monterey Peninsula Water Management District Resolution 2018-05 (3/19/2018)
- Division of Water Rights Response to Resolution 2018-05 (5/17/2018)
- Monterey Peninsula Water Management District Response (5/17/2018
- Monterey Peninsula Water Management District Response (5/18/2018)
- Agenda for Condition 2 Discussion Meeting (7/9/2018)
- List of Participants (7/9/2018)
Subscribe to our Water Rights Cal-Am Notifications email list to receive notifications and the latest updates. After subscribing, you will need to check your email host for a confirmation email to complete the subscription.
Subscribe to our other email lists. See the "Water Rights" section.
Past Correspondences Regarding Condition 2
When adopting Order WR 2016-0016, the State Water Board directed staff to meet with Monterey
Peninsula stakeholders regarding implementation of Condition 2 of Order WR 2009-0060, and to
report back. Condition 2 restricts new service connections, and any increases in water use at existing
service addresses resulting from a change in zoning or use. Clarifying amendments to Condition 2
were contemplated, but not adopted, in State Water Board Order 2016-0016. The documents that
follow are of past correspondences and meetings:
- SWRCB Response re: CPUC Decision 11-03-048 (4/9/2012)
- SWRCB Response re: Condition 2 of 2009-0060 (5/31/2013)
- California American Water et al comments (8/15/2016)
- Monterey Peninsula Water Management District comments (8/15/2016)
- MPWMD Exhibits (8/15/2016)
- Sierra Club & Carmel River Steelhead Assoc. Comments re: Condition 2 (9/2/2016)
- Monterey Peninsula Water Management District Cond 2 Presentation (12/13/2016)
- Luke Coletti Comments (12/13/2016)
- Luke Coletti Comments (12/19/2016)
- MPWMD Comments (1/3/2017)
- MPWMD Proposed Condition 2 Language (12/30/2016)
- Luke Coletti Email to Dave Stoldt (1/5/2017)
- Dave Stoldt's Response to Luke Coletti (1/5/2017)
- Luke Coletti's Response to Dave Stoldt (1/5/2017)
- Brian LeNeve (CRSA) Response (1/9/2017)
- Public Water Now Comments (1/10/2017)
- Carmel River Watershed Conservancy Comments (1/16/2017)
- Luke Coletti Comments (1/17/2017, updated 4/13/2017)
- Pacific Grove Chamber of Commerce Comments (1/18/2017)
- Monterey County Hospitality Association Comments (1/18/2017)
- Monterey Peninsula Chamber of Commerce Comments (1/18/2017)
- Monterey Peninsula Water Management District Email (1/18/2017)
- Coalition of Peninsula Businesses Comments (1/18/2017)
- Monterey Peninsula Water Management District Memo (1/18/2017)
- Monterey Commercial Property Owners Association Comments (1/19/2017)
- Monterey County Association of Realtors Comments (1/19/2017)
- Monterey Peninsula Regional Water Authority Comments (1/19/2017)
- Henry Ruhnke Comments (1/19/2017)
- Marriott Hotels & Resorts Comments (1/19/2017)
- Community Hospital of the Monterey Peninsula Comments (1/20/2017)
- City of Monterey Comments (1/20/2017)
- Luke Coletti Email (1/24/17)
- Dave Stoldt Email (1/24/17)
- Dave Stoldt Email to Luke Coletti (1/26/2017)
- Luke Coletti Email to Dave Stoldt (1/26/2017)
- Dave Stoldt Email to Luke Coletti (1/26/2017)
- Dave Stoldt Emails to SWRCB (1/26/2017)
- MPWMD Condition 2 Interpretation – Redline Version (1/26/2017)
- MPWMD Condition 2 Interpretation – Clean Version (1/26/2017)
- Luke Coletti Email to Dave Stoldt (1/27/2017)
- Anthony Davi Comments (1/27/2017)
- David Beech Comments (1/30/2017)
- John Hill Comments (2/1/2017)
- Planning & Conservation League/Sierra Club Comments (2/1/2017)
- Foothill Partners Comments (2/1/2017)
- Monterey County Hospitality Association Comments (2/2/2017)
- Michael Warburton Comments (2/3/2017)
- Amanasco Public Relations Comments (2/3/2017)
- Monterey Peninsula Regional Water Authority Comments (2/7/2017)
- Monterey Peninsula Water Management District Comments (3/2/2017)
- Luke Coletti Comments (3/9/2017)
- Sierra Club & Planning Conservation League Comments (3/10/2017)
- Monterey Peninsula Water Management District Comments (3/15/2017)
- Coalition of Peninsula Businesses Comments (3/17/2017)
- Paul Bruno Comments (3/19/3017)
- Chris Shake Comments 3/20/2017)
- Pacific Grove Chamber of Commerce Comments (3/20/2017)
- Monterey County Hospitality Association Comments (3/20/2017)
- Monterey Commercial Property Owners Association Comments (3/20/2017)
- Monterey County Association of Realtors Comments (3/20/2017)
- Monterey Peninsula Chamber of Commerce Comments (3/20/2017)
- Carmel River Steelhead Association Comments (3/21/2017)
- Sierra Club & Planning Conservation League Comments (3/27/2017)
- Dave Stoldt Response (3/31/2017)
- Luke Coletti Comments (3/27/2017, updated 4/13/2017)
- Dave Stoldt Credit Discussion (4/7/2017)
- Luke Coletti & Dave Laredo & MPWMD email exchange (4/10-12/2017)
- Luke Coletti Comments (4/19/2017)
- Luke Coletti Comments (6/24/2017)
- Monterey Peninsula Water Management District Comments (7/17/2017)
- Sierra Club Comments to July 17, 2017 MPWMD Letter (8/1/2017)
- Luke Coletti Comments (8/11/2017)
- Luke Coletti Comments (8/14/2017)
- Agenda for December 13, 2016 Meeting
Application to Modify Order WR 2016-0016
A joint application to modify Cease and Desist Order 2016-0016 was submitted by the Planning and Conservation League, Monterey One Water (formerly the Monterey Regional Water Pollution Control Agency), the Monterey Peninsula Water Management District, the Monterey Regional Water Authority, the Marina Coast Water District, Land Watch Monterey, the Sierra Club, Citizens for Just Water, the Public Trust Alliance and Public Water Now on May 9, 2018. The application seeks to add a parallel milestone tract, beginning in 2019, relating to the potential expansion of the Pure Water Monterey recycling project. The State Water Board has received the application, and a decision on whether to accept the application is currently pending.
The application specifically regards the milestones in condition 3.b.v. of Order WR 2016-0016, and related aspects of the proposed Monterey Peninsula Water Supply Project and Pure Water Monterey expansion project.
Please limit any communications regarding the application, aside from noncontroversial procedural matters, to written comments, which will be posted at this webpage as they are received.
- Planning & Conservation League et. al. Petition to Modify SWRCB Resolution 2016-0040 (5/9/2018)
- App to Modify Order WR 2016-0016 - Dismissal WithoutPrejudice (12/13/2019)
- App to Modify Order WR 2016-0016 - Ex Parte Comms Disclosure (12/12/2019)
- California-American Water Response to Application (6/7/2018)
- California-American Water Clarification email (6/14/2018)
- Marina Coast Water District Response to Application (6/29/2018)
- Ron Weitzman Commentary (7/11/2018)
- Ron Weitzman Commentary (7/20/2018)
- Marcia Wright Commentary (7/21/2018)
- Ron Weitzman Commentary (8/7/2018)
- Data Tampering Presentation (8/7/2018)
- John Moore Commentary (8/12/2018)
- John Moore Commentary (8/14/2018)
- Ron Weitzman Commentary (8/16/2018)
- John Moore Commentary (8/20/2018)
- Ron Weitzman Commentary (8/23/2018)
- Ron Weitzman Commentary (8/24/2018)
- John Moore Commentary (8/24/2018)
- John Moore Commentary (9/08/2018)
- John Moore Commentary (9/14/2018)
- Marc Del Piero Comments (9/15/2018)
- John Moore Commentary (12/30/2018)
- John Moore Commentary (1/17/2019)
- John Moore Commentary (1/21/2019)
- Public Water Now Letter (5/16/2019)
- Public Water Now Email (6/6/2019)
Application to Modify Order WR 2009-0060
On November 20, 2015, Cal-Am submitted a request to modify Order WR 2009-0060. On April 28, 2016, they filed an amended application requesting an extension of the compliance timeline until December 31, 2021, and other changes to the initial application. On July 19, 2016, the State Water Resources Control Board adopted Order WR 2016-0016 amending Order WR 2009-0060. Following adoption of Order WR 2016-0016, two petitions for reconsideration were timely filed by Water Ratepayers Association of the Monterey Peninsula (WRAMP, and aka WaterPlus) and by Public Trust Alliance. By Order WR 2016-0024 dated November 1, 2016, the State Water Board denied these petitions for reconsideration. Subsequently, on November 29, 2016, WRAMP filed a Petition for Writ of Mandate and Complaint for Declaratory and Injunctive Relief with the Superior Court of Sacramento County against Cal-Am and the State Water Board. On June 12, 2017, the Superior Court of Sacramento County dismissed WRAMP’s entire action with prejudice.
- National Marine Fisheries Service Position (9/14/2015)
- Initial Application to Modify Order WR 2009-0060 (11/20/2015)
- State Water Board Request for Clarification on Application (4/21/2016)
- Cal-Am Response to State Water Board's April 21, 2016 Letter (4/21/2016)
- Amended Application to Modify Order WR 2009-0060 (4/28/2016)
- State Water Board Public Notice on Request to Change WR 2009-0060 (5/6/2016)
- Preliminary Staff Recommendation to Modify Order WR 2009-0060 (6/17/2016)
- Rationale Document for Preliminary Staff Recommendation (6/17/2016)
- Draft Order for Consideration by the State Water Resources Control Board (7/15/16)
- Draft Resolution for Consideration by the State Water Resources Control Board (7/18/16)
- Order WR 2016-0016 amending Order WR 2009-0060 (7/19/2016)
Petition for Reconsideration of Order WR 2016-0016
- Ron Weitzman's email requesting Petition for Reconsideration (8/16/2016)
- Ron Weitzman Petition for Reconsideration (8/16/2016)
- Michael Warburton's email requesting Petition for Reconsideration (8/15/2016)
- Warburton Petition for Reconsideration (8/15/2016)
- Order WR 2016-0024 denying petition for reconsideration (11/1/2016)
Comments Received after Petitions for Reconsideration of WRO 2016-0016
- Ron Weitzman Request for Hearing (10/25/2016)
- Ron Weitzman Comments (10/23/2016)
- Michael Baer Comments (10/23/2016)
- Ron Weitzman Comments (10/22/2016)
- Robert Donlan's Objection to WRAMP's Second Supplement (10/7/2016)
- Ron Weitzman's Second Supplement to Petition for Reconsideration (9/30/2016)
- Return Water Fallacy Document (9/30/2016)
- Cal-Am et al. Response to Reconsideration Supplement (9/27/2016)
- Response to Petition for Reconsideration filed by Cal-Am et al. (9/2/2016)
- Luke Coletti Commentary re: Condition 2 (9/7/2016, updated 4/13/2017)
- Ron Weitzman Comments re: Change in Pipeline Material (9/19/2016)
- Ron Weitzman Petition for Reconsideration Supplement (9/20/2016)
- WRAMP Writ of Mandate (6/28/2016)
- Kevin Thomas Direct Testimony (5/22/2009)
- Robert MacLean Deposition (3/13/2012)
- Cal-Am Post-2011 CPUC Filing
- Carmel River Today 2014 Photos
Comments Received:
- Sierra Club - Planning & Conservation League (received 12/2/2015)
- Water Ratepayers Association of the Monterey Peninsula (11/23/2015)
- Dick Rotter Commentary (11/21/2015)
- Roy Thomas Commentary (12/14/2015)
- Monterey Peninsula WMD (12/14/2015)
- Monterey Bay Partisan - Ag Land Trust Wells (12/16/2015)
- PCL & Sierra Club Response (12/22/2015)
- Cal-Am response to Larry Silver (12/22/2015)
- Coalition of Peninsula Businesses (2/10/2016)
- California State Senate letter from William Monning (3/31/2016)
- Water Plus Email to the State Water Board (4/15/2016)
- Water Plus Email to the State Water Board (5/1/2016)
- State Water Board Response to Water Plus (5/11/2016)
- CPUC Letter Supporting Request to Change Order (5/24/2016)
- Roy Thomas Commentary (5/31/2016)
- Marina Coast Water District (5/31/2016)
- Luke Coletti Commentary (6/1/2016)
Comments Received After June 1, 2016:
- Jane Haines Comments (6/3/2016)
- Central Coast Regional Water Quality Control Board Comments (6/15/16)
- Ron Weitzman Comments (6/18/16)
- Cal-Am Response to Preliminary Recommendation (6/29/16)
- Jane Haines Comments (6/29/2016)
- Roy Thomas Comments (7/1/2016)
- Monterey Bay Aquarium Request & SWRCB Response (7/1/2016)
- Monterey County Hospitality Association Comments (7/3/2016)
- James Emery Comments (7/4/2016)
- Melodie Chrislock Comments (7/5/2016)
- Monterey County Association of Realtors (7/5/2016)
- Coalition of Peninsula Businesses Comments (7/5/2016)
- Trust for Public Land Comments (7/7/2016)
- Monterey Peninsula Chamber of Commerce (7/6/2016)
- Monterey Bay Aquarium Letter (7/6/2016)
- SWRCB Response to July 6, 2016 letter (7/7/2016)
- Rick Heuer Comments (7/8/2016)
- City of Monterey Comments (7/6/2016)
- Cannery Row Company Comments (7/7/2016)
- City of Pacific Grove Comments (7/8/2016)
- Community Hospital of the Monterey Peninsula Comments (7/1/2016)
- Cal-Am Additional Comments to Preliminary Staff Recommendation (7/8/2016)
- Public Water Now Comments (6/28/2016)
- Sierra Club, Planning & Conservation League Comments (7/11/2016)
- Monterey Peninsula Regional Water Authority Comments (7/8/2016)
- Jessie Delahaie Trust Comments (7/8/2016)
- Sand City Comments (7/8/2016)
- Monterey Peninsula Water Management District Comments (7/8/2016)
- Wendy Matthews Comments (7/9/2016)
- Chris Shake Comments (7/11/2016)
- California Environmental Law Project Comments (7/11/2016)
- Lindy Levin Comments (7/5/2016)
- Richard Rotter Comments (7/7/2016)
- Dan Presser Comments (7/7/2016)
- Michael Baer Comments (7/7/2016)
- Monterey Council Business Council Comments (7/11/2016)
- David Beech Comments (7/12/2016)
- Carmel River Steelhead Association Comments (7/12/2016)
- Monterey Marriott Comments (7/12/2016)
- Marina Coast Water District Comments (7/12/2016)
- Sam Farr, U.S. House of Representative Comments (7/8/2016)
- Monterey Commercial Property Owners Assoc. Comments (7/11/2016)
- City of Carmel By The Sea Comments (7/11/2016)
- George Riley, Monterey Herald Comments (7/12/2016)
- Monterey Bay Aquarium Letter (7/12/2016)
- Ron Weitzman Comments (7/13/2016)
- Rudy Fischer Comments (7/12/2016)
- MidPen Housing Comments (7/11/2016)
- Patrick Aldinger Comments (7/11/2016)
- Mark Stone, California Assembly Comments (7/13/2016)
- Carmel River Watershed Conservancy Comments (7/12/2016)
- 1st Capital Bank Comments (7/13/2016)
- City of Monterey Comments (7/13/2016)
- Anthony Davi Comments (7/13/2016)
- Ellen Gannon Comments (7/13/2016)
- Neal Heckman Comments (7/13/2016)
- Hopkins Groundwater Consultants Comments (7/13/2016)
- Thomas Jamison Comments (7/13/2016)
- Jason Burnett Comments (7/13/2016)
- Jeff Davi Comments (7/13/2016)
- Jane Haines Comments (7/13/2016)
- Luke Coletti Comments (7/13/2016)
- Anthony Lombardo Comments (7/13/2016)
- John Mahoney Comments (7/11/2016)
- Michelle Knight Comments (7/13/2016)
- William Monning, California State Senate Comments (7/11/2016)
- Montage Health Comments (7/12/2016)
- Monterey County Board of Supervisors Comments (7/12/2016)
- Nicholas Jacobs Comments (7/13/2016)
- Public Trust Alliance Comments (7/13/2016)
- Douglas Roberts Comments (7/13/2016)
- John Schatz Comments (7/13/2016)
- Nancy Selfridge Comments (7/13/2016)
- Shirley Moon Comments (7/13/2016)
- Vicki Tackett Comments (7/13/2016)
- Mark Watson Comments (7/13/2016)
- Jacqueline Zischke Comments (7/13/2016)
- Mark Eckles Comments (7/12/2016)
- William Hood Comments (7/8/2016)
- SWRCB Response to July 8, 2016 Comments (7/8/2016)