State Water Resources Control Board

Storm Water Program

Phase II Small Municipal Permit

PUBLIC COMMENTS REGARDING PHASE II SMALL MS4 GENERAL PERMIT

The State Water Board invited the public to comment on the draft Tentative Order for the Phase II Small MS4 General Permit (June 2011). The Water Board staff subsequently responded to the public comments. The numbered, annotated version of the comment letters correspond to numbers in the staff's Response to Comments document.

Public Notice | Revised Public Notice (deadline extended to September 8, 2011)
Staff Response to Comments
Program Page

Number	Company	Representative's Original Letter	Representative's Annotated Version
1	Atascadero Unified School District	Deborah Bowers	Deborah Bowers
2	Bay Area Stormwater Management Agencies	James Scanlin	James Scanlin
3	Bay-Friendly Landscaping & Gardening Coalition	Anne Cook	Anne Cook
4	Belli Architectural Group	Raymond Belli	Raymond Belli
5	BNSF Railway	Edward Phillips	Edward Phillips (2.7 MB)
6	Butte County Board of Supervisors	Steve Lambert	Steve Lambert
7	Calaveras County Public Works	Robert Pachinger	Robert Pachinger
8	California Association of School Business Officials	Dennis Meyers	Dennis Meyers
9	California Chamber of Commerce	Valerie Nera	Valerie Nera
10	California Coalition for Adequate School Housing	Kathy Tanner	Kathy Tanner
11	California Council for Environmental and Economic Balance	Robert Lucas Gerald Secundy	Robert Lucas Gerald Secundy
12	California County Superintendents Educational Services Association	Michael Hulsizer	Michael Hulsizer
13	California Grocers Association California Retailers Association California Restaurant Associatio	Kara Bush Missy Johnson Matthew Sutton	Kara Bush Missy Johnson Matthew Sutton
14	California State Association of Counties Regional Council of Rural Counties League of California Cities	Karen Keene Staci Heaton Kyra Ross	Karen Keene Staci Heaton Kyra Ross
15	California State Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation	Chris Meyer	Chris Meyer
16	California State Department of Parks and Recreation	Anthony Perez Daphne Greene	Anthony Perez Daphne Greene (1.7 MB)
17	California Stormwater Quality Association	Scott Taylor	Scott Taylor (1.6 MB)
18	Central Coast Long-Term Environmental Assessment Network	Dane Hardin	Dane Hardin
19	Central Valley Clean Water Association	Debbie Webster	Debbie Webster
20	Citadel Equities Group, LLC.	Sheri Taylor	Sheri Taylor
21	City of Arroyo Grande	Teresa McClish	Teresa McClish
22	City of Atascadero	Russell Thompson	Russell Thompson
23	City of Banning	Duane Burk	Duane Burk
24	City of Buelton	Rose Hess	Rose Hess
25	City of Carmel by the Sea	Sean Conroy	Sean Conroy
26	City of Ceres	Toby Wells	Toby Wells
27	City of Cloverdale	Gus Wolter	Gus Wolter
28	City of El Paso de Robles	Matt Thompson	Matt Thompson
29	City of Healdsburg	Michael Kim	Michael Kim
30	City of Lompoc	John Linn	John Linn (1.9 MB)
31	City of Malibu	Jim Thorsen	Jim Thorsen
32	City of Monterey	Chuck Della Sala	Chuck Della Sala
33	City of Morro Bay	Williamm Yates	Williamm Yates
34	City of Napa	Jill Techel	Jill Techel (1.1 MB)
35	City of Patterson	Rod Butler	Rod Butler
36	City of Pismo Beach	Shelly Higginbotham	Shelly Higginbotham
37	City of Redding	Kurt Starman	Kurt Starman
38	City of Riverbank	J.D. Hightower	J.D. Hightower
39	City of Rocklin	Rick Horst	Rick Horst
40	City of Roseville	Pauline Roccucci	Pauline Roccucci (2.2 MB)
41	City of San Diego Transportation & Storm Water Department	Kris McFadden	Kris McFadden
42	City of San Luis Obispo	Katie Lichtig	Katie Lichtig
43	City of Santa Barbara	Cameron Benson	Cameron Benson
44	City of Santa Clarita	Travis Lange	Travis Lange
45	City of Santa Maria	Richard Sweet	Richard Sweet (1.5 MB)
46	City of Santa Rosa	Miles Ferris	Miles Ferris
47	City of Sonoma	Linda Kelly	Linda Kelly
48	City of Sonoma	Wendy Atkins Milenka Bates	Wendy Atkins Milenka Bates
49	City of Tracy	R. Leon Churchill	R. Leon Churchill (2.6 MB)
50	City of Turlock	Dan Madden	Dan Madden
51	City of Ukiah	Tim Eriksen	Tim Eriksen
52	City of Vacaville	Royce Cunningham	Royce Cunningham
53	City of Watsonville	Daniel Dodge	Daniel Dodge
54	City of Wheatland	Dane Schilling	Dane Schilling
55	City of Woodland	Mark Deven	Mark Deven
56	City of Yreka	Rory McNeil	Rory McNeil
57	Coalition for Practical Regulation	Larry Forester	Larry Forester (1.3 MB)
58	College of the Canyons	Carl Ebaugh	Carl Ebaugh
59	Contra Costa Community College District	Ray Pyle	Ray Pyle
60	Contractors Association of Truckee Tahoe	Pat Davison	Pat Davison
61	County of El Dorado	James Ware	James Ware
62	County of Kern	Kevin Hamilton Charles Lackey	Kevin Hamilton Charles Lackey (1.1 MB)
63	County of Los Angeles, Department of Public Works	Gail Farber	Gail Farber
64	County of Mendocino	Kendall Smith	Kendall Smith
65	County of Riverside	Michael Shelter	Michael Shelter
66	County of San Bernardino	Granville Bowman	Granville Bowman (1.5 MB)
67	County of San Luis Obispo	Adam Hill	Adam Hill
68	County of Santa Barbara	Chandra Wallar	Chandra Wallar
69	County of Santa Clara	Jody Hall Esser	Jody Hall Esser
70	County of Santa Cruz	John Presleigh Robert Kennedy	John Presleigh Robert Kennedy
71	County of Sonoma	Reg Cullen	Reg Cullen
72	County School Facilities Consortium	Anna Ferrera	Anna Ferrera
73	Department of Defense, Region 9	CL Stathos	CL Stathos
74	Department of the Navy	Patricia McFadden	Patricia McFadden
75	Downey Unified School District	Buck Weinfurter	Buck Weinfurter
76	FAMCO Holdings	Brendan Finn	Brendan Finn
77	Gallinas Watershed Council	Russ Greenfield	Russ Greenfield
78	General Public	Bruce Lund	Bruce Lund
79	General Public	Joyce Dillard	Joyce Dillard
80	General Public	Teresa Jordan	Teresa Jordan
81	Hemet Unified School District	Steven Lowder	Steven Lowder
82	Humboldt Baykeeper	Beth Werner Michelle Smith	Beth Werner Michelle Smith
83	Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory	Bruce Schultz	Bruce Schultz
84	Los Angeles Community Colleges	Tom Hall	Tom Hall (2.9 MB)
85	Los Angeles County Office of Education	Pamela Gibbs	Pamela Gibbs
86	Los Angeles Department of Water and Power	Katherine Rubin	Katherine Rubin
87	Los Angeles Unified School District	Richard Luke	Richard Luke
88	Los Osos Community Service District	Dan Gilmore	Dan Gilmore
89	Lucia Mar Unified School District	Kevin Baker	Kevin Baker
90	MacKay & Somps	Ken Giberson	Ken Giberson
91	Marin Conservation League	Susan Stompe	Susan Stompe
92	Marin County Department of Public Works	Terri Fashing	Terri Fashing
93	Mendocino County Office of Education	Paul Tichinin Vicki Todd Stephen Turner	Paul Tichinin Vicki Todd Stephen Turner
94	Mendocino County Office of Education	Paul Tichinin	Paul Tichinin
95	Mojave River Watershed Group	Nancy Sansonetti	Nancy Sansonetti (1.6 MB)
96	Monterey County Department of Public Works	Thomas Harty	Thomas Harty
97	Monterey County Hospitality Association	Janine Chicourrat	Janine Chicourrat
98	Monterey County Mayors’ Association	David Pendergrass	David Pendergrass
99	Monterey Regional Stormwater Permit Participants Group	Sydney Moe	Sydney Moe
100	Napa Chamber of Commerce	Ryan Gregory Lisa Batto	Ryan Gregory Lisa Batto
101	Napa County Flood Control and Water Conservation District	Jill Techel	Jill Techel
102	Natural Resource Defense Council Heal the Bay California Coastkeeper Alliance	Noah Garrison Kirsten James Sara Aminzadeh	Noah Garrison Kirsten James Sara Aminzadeh
103	NG Alexander Real Estate Development LLC	N.G. Alexander	N.G. Alexander
104	Nine Mile Hill Investment Company	Michael George	Michael George (1.3 MB)
105	North Bay Watershed Association	Jack Gibson	Jack Gibson
106	Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment	George Alexeeff	George Alexeeff
107	Orange County Department of Education	Andrea Sullivan	Andrea Sullivan
108	Paso Robles Public Schools	Kathleen McNamara	Kathleen McNamara
109	Peninsula Corridor Joint Powers Board	Chuck Harvey	Chuck Harvey
110	Placer County Department of Public Works	Ken Grehm	Ken Grehm (2.8 MB)
111	Placer Regional Stormwater Coordination Group Placer County City of Roseville City of Rocklin City of Lincoln City of Auburn Town of Loomis	Ken Grehm Pauline Roccucci George Magnuson Jim Estep Bernie Schroder Perry Beck	Ken Grehm Pauline Roccucci George Magnuson Jim Estep Bernie Schroder Perry Beck
112	Port of San Francisco City and County of San Francisco Public Utilities Commission	Monique Moyer Tommy Moala	Monique Moyer Tommy Moala
113	Richland Communities	Clifton Taylor	Clifton Taylor
114	Riverside County Flood Control and Water Conservation District	Jason Uhley	Jason Uhley (2.4 MB)
115	Riverside County Transportation Department	Juan Perez	Juan Perez
116	Russian River Watershed Association	Jake Mackenzie	Jake Mackenzie
117	Sacramento Stormwater Quality Partnership	Richard Lorenz	Richard Lorenz
118	San Diego County Office of Education Municipal Stormwater Group	Joanne Branch	Joanne Branch
119	San Diego Regional Water Quality Control Board	David Barker	David Barker
120	San Diego Unified School District – Facilities Planning & Construction	James Watts	James Watts
121	San Diego Unified School District Auxiliary Services	Drew Rowlands	Drew Rowlands
122	San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District	Nancy Lowenthal	Nancy Lowenthal
123	San Francisco Baykeeper	Jason Flanders Ian Wren Abigail Blodgett	Jason Flanders Ian Wren Abigail Blodgett
124	San Gabriel Unified School District	Ralph Patterson	Ralph Patterson
125	San Luis Costal Unified School District	Russell Miller	Russell Miller
126	San Mateo County Transit District	Chuck Harvey	Chuck Harvey
127	Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District	Janece Maez	Janece Maez
128	Signature Homes	Stephen Hicks	Stephen Hicks
129	Solano County Department of Resource Management	Matt Tuggle Nicholas Burton	Matt Tuggle Nicholas Burton
130	Sonoma Valley Chamber of Commerce	Jennifer Yankovich	Jennifer Yankovich
131	Specialty Steel Service	Joseph McCaslin	Joseph McCaslin
132	Stanislaus County	Laurie Barton	Laurie Barton
133	Stanislaus County	Matt Machado	Matt Machado (5.2 MB)
134	Statewide Stormwater Coalition: City of Atascadero City of Carmel by the Sea City of Davi City of Auburn City of Ceres City of Del Rey Oaks City of Lincoln City of Pacific Grove City of San Luis Obispo City of Lodi City of Paso Robles City of Sand City City of Lompoc City of Patterson City of Santa Maria City of Marina City of Pismo Beach City of Seaside City of Monterey City of Placerville City of Sonoma City of Morro Bay City of Riverbank City of Tracy City of Napa City of Rocklin City of Watsonville City of Newman City of Roseville City of Woodland City of Yuba City County of San Bernardino County of Yolo Town of Loomis County of San Luis Obispo California Chapters of the American Public Works Association Town of Truckee County of Santa Cruz California State Association of Counties County of Butte County of Shasta League of California Cities County of Monterey County of Sonoma Regional Council of Rural Counties County of Placer County of Stanislaus Shasta County Water Agency	Russell Thompson John Goss William Marshall Bernie Schroeder Chris Vierra Jerry Edelen Jim Estep Thomas Frutchey Jan Marx Konradt Bartlam Matt Thompson Richard Simonitch Laurel Barcelona Rod Butler Larry Lavagnino Anthony Altfeld Shelly Higginbotham Ray Corpuz Chuck Della Sala M. Cleve Morris Linda Kelly Andrea Lueker JD Hightower Brent Ives Jill Techel George Magnuson Robert Ketley Garner Reynolds Pauline Roccucci Mark Deven Steve Jepsen Granville Bowman Matt Rexroad Perry Beck Adam Hill Doug Fredericks Tony Lashbrook John Presleigh Karen Keene Mike Crump Patrick Minturn Kyra Ross Yazdan Emrani Reg Cullen Staci Heaton Ken Grehm Mat Machado Patrict Minturn	Russell Thompson John Goss William Marshall Bernie Schroeder Chris Vierra Jerry Edelen Jim Estep Thomas Frutchey Jan Marx Konradt Bartlam Matt Thompson Richard Simonitch Laurel Barcelona Rod Butler Larry Lavagnino Anthony Altfeld Shelly Higginbotham Ray Corpuz Chuck Della Sala M. Cleve Morris Linda Kelly Andrea Lueker JD Hightower Brent Ives Jill Techel George Magnuson Robert Ketley Garner Reynolds Pauline Roccucci Mark Deven Steve Jepsen Granville Bowman Matt Rexroad Perry Beck Adam Hill Doug Fredericks Tony Lashbrook John Presleigh Karen Keene Mike Crump Patrick Minturn Kyra Ross Yazdan Emrani Reg Cullen Staci Heaton Ken Grehm Mat Machado Patrict Minturn (3.5 MB)
135	Sun City Roseville Homeowners Association	Jeanne Clark	Jeanne Clark
136	Tallman Communities Real Estate Development & Entitlements	John Tallman	John Tallman
137	The Otter Project Monterey Coastkeeper	Steve Shimek	Steve Shimek
138	Todd Engineers	Raymond Will	Raymond Will
139	Town of Paradise	Alan White	Alan White
140	Town of Truckee	Richard Anderson	Richard Anderson (2.6 MB)
141	Town of Windsor	Richard Burtt	Richard Burtt
142	United States Environmental Protection Agency, Region 9	David Smith	David Smith
143	University of California	Robert Charbonneau	Robert Charbonneau
144	Valley Contractors Exchange	Kate Leyden	Kate Leyden
145	Ventura County Office of Education	Ken Prosser	Ken Prosser
146	WateReuse California	David Smith	David Smith
147	Weiss Associates	Scott Bourne Agata Sulczynski Bob Devany	Scott Bourne Agata Sulczynski Bob Devany
148	West Coast Housing Partners, LLC	Rick Langdon	Rick Langdon
149	Westpark Associates	Jeff Jones	Jeff Jones
150	Wood Rodgers	Jennifer Hanson	Jennifer Hanson
151	Woodland Chamber of Commerce	Tom Galeazzi	Tom Galeazzi
Date	Late Comments		Representative
2/21/12	California Stormwater Quality Association		Richard Boon
12/16/11	California Stormwater Quality Association		Scott Taylor
Date	Memorandum Disclosing CASQA Communication with State Board		Representative
05/25/12	CASQA and State Water Resources Control Board		State Water Board

For further information please contact:

Ali Dunn: (916) 341-6899 - adunn@waterboards.ca.gov
or
Eric Berntsen: (916) 341-5911 - eberntsen@waterboards.ca.gov
or
Christine Sotelo: (916) 322-1400 - csotelo@waterboards.ca.gov